Currently not accepting online orders
Benny's Deli
1183 Erbs Quarry Road, Lititz, PA
Food
Bagels and Bread
Kaiser Roll
$1.50asiago
$1.50Blueberry Bagel
$1.50cinnamon raisin
$1.50Egg Bagel
$1.50Everything Bagel
$1.50french toast
$1.50Gluten Free Bagel
$2.50Jalapeno
$1.50Plain Bagel
$1.50Pumpernickle
$1.50Sesame
$1.50Hero (Seeded)
$2.00Hero (Non-Seeded)
$2.00Pumpkin
$1.50
Breakfast Sandwiches
Bacon, Egg, Cheese
$5.50Sausage, Egg, Cheese
$5.50Egg and Cheese
$4.00Cream Cheese and Bacon
$4.00Buttered Roll
$1.50Lox and Capers Sandwich
$10.00Bacon and egg
$5.50Sausage and egg
$5.50
Focaccia Sandwiches
Build your own Foccacia sandwich
$14.00Fico
Prosciutto, burrata, fig jam, arugula, balsamic glaze$14.00Inferno
Hot capocollo, spicy soppressata, proscuitto cotto, mozzarella, spicy sauce$14.00La Nonna
Sweet Capocollo, mozzarella, Nonna's zucchini, olive oil$14.00La Paradiso
Mortadella, stracciatella cheese, pistachio cream, chopped pistachio$14.00Primavera
Roasted red peppers, zucchini, roasted tomatoes, pesto$14.00Romano
$14.00Tartufo
Italian ham, pecorino cheese, basil, truffle cream$14.00
Classic Sandwiches
Kaiser
Seeded Hero
Non-Seeded Hero
Pastrami on rye
$15.00GLUTEN FREE
BYO classic Sandwich- KAISER
$11.00BYO classic sandwich- HERO
$15.00BYO Rye
$10.00BYO KIDS- ONLY MEAT AND CHEESE
$9.00
Sweets
2 FOR 25 COOKIES
OUT OF STOCK$25.00Biscotti
$1.75Cannoli
$2.00Chocolate Caprese Cake
Cinnamon Bun
OUT OF STOCKMuffin
$2.25Croissant with Pistachio Cream or Nutella
$4.00Individual cookie from case (specify which)
$1.50Jumbo Rice Krispy Treat
$4.00Lemon Caprese Cake
Nana's Crumb Cake
$4.00Sfogliatelle
$3.00Toasted Panettone
Croissant
$2.25Candy Apple
$2.00
SPECIALS
italian pork sandwich
$12.00+deli chicken BLT
$15.00Meat Bread
$8.50Sausage
Biscuit sami
$4.00Rye,egg,tomato
$4.00Muffuletta
$10.00
Soup
Italian Wedding
$4.00
Coffee
Coffee
Drip Coffee
$2.50+Drip Coffee- DECAF
$2.50+Latte
$4.00+Mocha
$4.50+Americano
$3.50+Cortado
$3.00Cappuccino
$4.00+Flat White
$4.00+Cold Brew
$4.00+iced coffee
$3.00+Shaken Espresso
$4.00+Matcha
(Need to find a good brand) https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTkvfk6DD/$5.50+Hot Chocolate
$3.50+Chai
(Need to find a good brand)$4.00+Tea
(Hot and maybe iced?)$1.50+Espresso
$1.50+Choc Milk 12oz
$3.00
Coffee Specials
Italian Rainbow Cookie cold brew
chocolate drizzle, almond flavoring, and raspberry cold foam$5.75+Pistachio Latte
Pistachio butter, pistachio flavoring, brown sugar cold foam, pistachio crumble on top$5.00+Brown Sugar Shaken
$4.00+Strawberry Matcha
$6.00+Black and white cookie latte
$5.00+Free Coffee Special
Pumpkin Roll Latte
$5.00+
Market
PASTA
DM Macaroni
$6.00DM Mista Corta
$6.00DM Rigatoni
OUT OF STOCK$6.00DM Spaghetti
$6.00Granoro Cut Ziti
$3.25Granoro Ditali
$3.25Granoro Fettuccine
$3.25Granoro GF Penne Rigate
$6.00Granoro Mezzi Rigatoni
$3.25LaMolisana Cavatappi
$4.00LaMolisana Farfalle Rigate
$4.00LaMolisana Penne Ziti Rigate
$4.00Nonna Carmen Mushroom Risotto
$6.50Nonna Carmen Saffron Risotto
$6.50Nonna Carmen Truffle Risotto
$6.50Scotti Risotto
$9.00
SAUCES
Granaro Strained Tomatoes
$5.00Nonna Carmen Marinara
OUT OF STOCK$8.50Nonna Carmen Alfredo
OUT OF STOCK$11.00Nonna Carmen Vodka Sauce
OUT OF STOCK$10.00San Marzano Tomato Rega
$7.50
OIL
Casa Ligaro Olive Oil
$25.00
CRACKERS/COOKIES
Bagel Chips
$2.00Baiocchi Pistacchio
$8.00Bauli Amaretti
$5.00BPB Almond Biscotti
$16.00BPB Anisette Biscotti
$16.00BPB Assorted Cookies
$15.00BPB Assorted Vanilla Cookies
$15.00BPB B&W cookies
$15.00BPB Breadsticks
$6.00BPB Cannoli Cookies
$15.00BPB ChocChip
$15.00BPB Chocolate Fudge
$15.00BPB Lemon Biscotti
$16.00BPB Lemon Bites
$15.00BPB Mini Linzer Tart
$15.00BPB Rasp Sprinkle Sandwich
$15.00BPB Raspberry Sandwich
$15.00BPB Seven Layer
$15.00BPB Spumoni Biscotti
$16.00BPB Sugar Free Cookies
$15.00Colacchio Tarallucci al Finocchio
$5.00Colacchio Tarallucci Tradizionali
$5.00Grissini Vegan Breadsticks
$4.00La Panzanella Rosemary Crackers
$6.00Mulino Bianco Abbracci
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Mulino Bianco Baiocchi Pistacchio
$9.00Mulino Bianco Settembrini
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Nutella Bisquits
$6.00Rosemary Crostini
$5.00Mulino Cuor do Mela
$7.00Lady Fingers
$11.00Ore Liete Choc Croissant large
$10.00Cioccolato
$2.00Dora3 Croissant
$2.00Dora3 Croissant large
$10.00Lambertz Gbread stars
$8.00Labertz Gbread Men
$9.00
CONDIMENTS
Quattro Ciok Pistachio Cream
$25.00Nutella
$15.00Solo Calabria Sun dried peppers
$14.00Solo Calabria Acacia Honey
$15.00Muraca Marinated Artichokes
$8.00Muraca Mushrooms Calabria
$10.00Bella Sielia Eggplant Caponata
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Cosmos Imported Capers
$4.00Coccia Truffle Salt
$15.00Original Premium Fig Spread
$12.00loewensenf medium
$6.50mini Gherkins
$6.50sauerkraut
$7.00Blue Cheese Olives
$11.00Edmond Fallot Dijon Mustard
$5.00Edmond Fallot Seed Mustard
$5.00Colavita Artichoke Patee
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Red Cabbage
$7.00Black Olive Spread
$8.00De Nigris Aged Balsamic Vinegar
$16.00Colavita Balsamic Vinegar
$6.00Colavita EVOO
$20.00De Nigris Balsamic Vinegar Glaze
$12.00Pesto Genovese
$8.50Fruit Spread
$6.00Kimbo
$13.00Borbone Crema Classica
$12.00Borbone Italian Roast
$13.00Borbone Breakfast Blend
$13.00Garlic Salt
$8.50Lemon Pepper Salt
$8.50
Cold Items
Sapor Sporessata Sweet
$16.00Sapor Sporessata Hot
$16.00Pecorino Sale Plain
$16.00Pecorino Sale Red Pepper
$16.00Eggs
$2.50Caputo Mozzarella
$8.00Stracciatella
$11.00Container sausage
$5.00Burrata
$9.00
Chips\candy
Salt & Vinegar Chips
$1.50Jalapeno Chips
$1.50BBQ Chips
OUT OF STOCK$1.50Sea Salt Chips
OUT OF STOCK$1.50San Carlo Classic
OUT OF STOCK$2.50Cerelia Original
$2.00Cerelia Sparkeling
$2.00Lays Classic
$1.50Lays BBQ
$1.50Lays S/V
$1.50Lays SCO
$1.50Cape Cod
$1.25Lays Wavy
$1.50BelVita
$1.25Candy Bar
$2.00Italian Jelly Candies
$7.00Swedish Candy
$8.50San Carlo Wavy
$2.50Nougat-Tiramisu
$5.50Nougat-Limon
$5.50Nougat-Caramel
$5.50Nougat-Creme
$5.50Nougat-Rasberry
$5.50Spritz Pastigle
$3.25Limone
$3.25Pesto Chips
$3.50Panforte Margherita
$10.50
Soda Cooler
Aquafina
$2.00Diet Pepsi
$2.50Dr. Pepper
$2.50Gatorade Orange
$2.50Gatorade Red
$2.50Gatorade Yellow
$2.50La Dolce Vita
$2.75Limonata
$2.75Mountain Dew
$2.50Pepsi
$2.50Poppi Cherry Lime
$2.75Poppi Classic
$2.75Poppi Orange Cream
$2.75Poppi Shirley Temple
$2.75Poppi Strawberry
$2.75Poppi Wild Berry
$2.75Pure Leaf Lemon
$2.75Pure Leaf Peach
$2.75Pure Leaf Raspberry
$2.75S.Pellegrino
$2.00Sanpellegrino
$2.00Stary
$2.50Tropicana Orange
OUT OF STOCK$2.75
BPB Misc
Everything Breadsticks
OUT OF STOCKSesame Breadsticks
OUT OF STOCKSesame S Cookies
OUT OF STOCKRed Pepper Taralli
Lady Fingers Cookies
Sugar Cookies
OUT OF STOCKRaspberry Moon Cookies
OUT OF STOCKRaspberry Nut Cookies
OUT OF STOCKSicilian Cookies
Pocket Cookies
OUT OF STOCK
Merch
Shirt
$15.00Dish soap
$10.00Hand soap
$8.50
Drinks
Soda Fridge
Gatorade
$2.50Orange juice
$2.75Poppi
$2.25Soda
$2.50Tea
$2.75Water bottle
$2.00Apple Juice
$2.00Smart Water
$2.75Choc Milk
$2.75
Gelato
Vanilla
$3.50+Vanilla honey
$3.50+Nutella
$3.50+Hazelnut
$3.50+Chocolate
$3.50+Raspberry sorbet
$3.50+Blood orange sorbet
$3.50+Stracciatella (chocolate chip)
$3.50+Pistachio
$3.50+mint cc
$3.50+AFFOGATO
$4.50+
Deli
Salads (Copy)
Aunt Jackie's Potato Salad ($9/lb)
$2.25+Pasta Primavera ($8/lb)
$2.00+Pasta with Pesto ($9/lb)
$2.25+Cucumber Salad ($6/lb)
$1.50+Tuna Salad ($10/lb)
$2.50+Veggie Salad ($6/lb)
$1.50+Cole Slaw ($6/lb)
$1.50+Chicken Salad ($10/lb)
$2.50+White Fish ($10/lb)
$2.50+
MISC
Olives ($10/lb)
Roasted red peppers ($8/lb)
Pickles ($4/lb)
Hero (Seeded)
$2.00
1